DiamondRing.com

DiamondRing.com (http://www.diamondring.com/forums/index.php)
-   DIAMONDS (http://www.diamondring.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=1)
-   -   colour, clarity, or cut? choosing between 3 (http://www.diamondring.com/forums/showthread.php?t=153354)

iggs 07-20-12 01:48 AM

colour, clarity, or cut? choosing between 3
 
Please help! I'm choosing between 3 really good diamonds. Let me know your opinions on these:

#1: 1.25 carat, D colour, si1 clarity, very good cut

#2: 1.35 carat, F colour, vsi1 clariy, very good cut

#3: 1.22 carat, F colour, si1 clarity, ideal cut

If price was not a factor, which would you choose?
:)
Iggs

irish 08-15-12 01:29 AM

Re: colour, clarity, or cut? choosing between 3
 
How well a diamond is Cut can improve how the Color and Clarity appear to the eye.

Jan 08-22-12 12:37 PM

Re: colour, clarity, or cut? choosing between 3
 
I would probably go with the ideal cut.

DiamondAdvice 09-20-12 07:11 AM

Re: colour, clarity, or cut? choosing between 3
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by iggs
Please help! I'm choosing between 3 really good diamonds. Let me know your opinions on these:

#1: 1.25 carat, D colour, si1 clarity, very good cut

#2: 1.35 carat, F colour, vsi1 clariy, very good cut

#3: 1.22 carat, F colour, si1 clarity, ideal cut

If price was not a factor, which would you choose?
:)
Iggs


Cut = brilliance and sparkle
With regard to carat weight, you need to be careful and compare the diameter of each diamond, not just go by what the grading report says for carat weight. A well cut diamond will face up larger than a poor or inferior cut diamond. I'd say that a 1.25ct diamond should have a diameter of around 6.85-6.95mm.

As far as color goes, you will not be able to detect the difference between a D or F, so that is really a moot point.

Clarity will be an issue with some SI1's so be sure to know what inclusions there are and where they are. Eye-clean is what you are aiming for, a diamond that has no visible inclusions from 8-12 inches when looking at it face-up in normal lighting conditions.

Icerocc 02-08-13 02:53 PM

Re: colour, clarity, or cut? choosing between 3
 
I would go with #1 D color is the best.

rodentman 02-13-13 04:39 PM

Wrong.
 
F will appear indistinguishable from a D. Ideal cut trumps very good cut and it is highly likely to make a noticeable positive difference.


All times are GMT -4. The current time is 12:47 AM.

Powered by: vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2019, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.